Log in

No account? Create an account
Black & White
Last Icon Maker Standing
Round Seven: Challenge Nine — Voting!!!!!! 
10th-Dec-2009 09:35 am
Daniel Craig || CR | V/B
I haven't forgotten. :P Given that I am completely finished with school this year, I don't foresee too many more obstacles to finishing this round.

Voting Rules
Please use the following form when voting.
IF YOU ENTERED AN ICON, YOU ARE EXPECTED TO VOTE. If you do not vote, you cannot win people's choice or mod's choice (thanks to sidhex3 for the idea)
Vote for your TWO (2) least favorite icons and ONE (1) favorite icon. Icons can be from any theme. Don't stick to one theme on purpose.
ALL votes must have valid and non-opinionated reasons for why you voted for or against the icon. Remember to vote on quality NOT preference. See here for help on writing effective comments.
Do NOT vote for OR against your icon or ask anyone to vote for/against you.
ALL submitted icons must remain anonymous until results have been posted.

Please take the time to consider a few things when voting:
Aim for votes to be 1 - 2 complete sentences
If you can expand, do!
WHY & WHERE - why is it a bad thing, where is it happening?
If you're feeling helpful you can also offer a HOW it could be improved.

i.e. If the icon is too dark, explain why that is a negative thing (subject blends into the background, loss of definition etc). Oversharpened? Tell me where!
Blatantly stolen from truebloodlims

Results will be posted Friday/Saturday morning.
REMEMBER: you are expected to vote if you submitted an icon
We will be eliminating one person.
If you have any questions, please ask!

1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8

10th-Dec-2009 11:12 pm (UTC)
Least Favorite Icons
#6 - The centered & head/shoulders composition is boring as it's so traditional. The high contrast of the her hair and neck (especially compared to #4) combined with the darkness of the edges is overpowering.
#5 - There's just not enough happening, the picture itself doesn't say enough to leave it without either text or more context from the original photo. The crop would be good if there was more negative space above him. The lighting and contrast isn't handled as well as in the other icons.

Favorite Icon
#4 - Technically speaking I think it's the best of the group. The light and contrast are perfect and the text is very well done. Not my favorite subject, but a nice icon.
This page was loaded May 20th 2018, 9:16 pm GMT.